← Seller guides

Are “We Buy Houses” Companies a Scam? 8 Red Flags to Check

8 red flags when selling to cash buyers

Most "we buy houses" companies are legitimate businesses, not scams, though their cash offers usually come in below what a listing might bring.

The warning signs are specific behaviors, such as an upfront fee, pressure to sign, or a hidden plan to assign the contract. Each flag below comes with a way to check it, followed by where to report a problem and what five states require.

This is general information, not legal advice. State rules vary.

Jump to a section
  1. How to check a cash buyer
  2. Red flag 1: Upfront fees
  3. Red flag 2: Pressure to sign
  4. Red flag 3: No proof of funds
  5. Red flag 4: No track record
  6. Red flag 5: Vague answers
  7. Red flag 6: Last-minute changes
  8. Red flag 7: Offers above market
  9. Red flag 8: No title company
  10. How to protect yourself
  11. Where to report a problem
  12. State disclosure laws
  13. How Propcash can help
  14. Common questions

Do you already have a cash offer on your house?

Free. No obligation. You choose the closing date.

How to Check If a Cash Home Buyer Is Legit

A legitimate cash buyer passes checks that do not depend on its word: a registered company, recent proof of funds, earnest money with a neutral holder, and a contract a lawyer can read first. Earnest money is the buyer's deposit, which it may lose if it backs out for a reason the contract does not allow.

The ten questions guide has a table of each question, the document behind it, and where to confirm it. The guide to what to expect from cash buyers walks through a normal sale. The eight flags below are the same checks seen from the other side.

Red Flag #1: Requesting Upfront Fees

A request for money before closing is the clearest warning sign. A real buyer usually pays its own inspection and title costs, and any seller costs come out of the sale price at closing.

"It’s illegal for a company to charge you upfront for promises to help you get relief on paying your mortgage."

Federal Trade Commission, consumer advice on mortgage relief scams

  • What it looks like: a "processing" or "appraisal" fee due before a closing date is even set.
  • How to check it: the contract and the estimated settlement statement (the sheet of closing costs) list every seller cost. A fee outside them stands out.
  • What a legitimate buyer does instead: pays its own costs and asks the seller for nothing before closing.
An hourglass with sand running down on a dark table
Oklahoma's Real Estate Commission form notes a two-business-day right to cancel a wholesale contract.

Red Flag #2: High-Pressure Tactics and Artificial Urgency

Pressure to sign today is a warning sign because it leaves no time to read the contract or compare offers. A legitimate offer usually stays open long enough for a lawyer to read it.

  • What it looks like: an offer that "expires tonight," or a push to skip a lawyer's review.
  • How to check it: the buyer's response to a request for a full copy and a few days shows how it treats a seller's time.
  • What a legitimate buyer does instead: puts the offer in writing and welcomes a lawyer's reading.

Red Flag #3: Unable or Unwilling to Provide Proof of Funds

A cash buyer that cannot show proof of funds may not have the money to close. Proof of funds is a recent bank letter or statement showing cash on hand to cover the price.

  • What it looks like: no letter, an undated letter, or a letter in a different company's name than the contract.
  • How to check it: the bank that issued the letter, reached at a number from its own website, may confirm it. Some banks decline for privacy reasons.
  • What a legitimate buyer does instead: provides a recent letter in the name of the company that signs the contract.
Several hands holding up red cards
A buyer's track record can be checked in the state business registry and county property records.

Red Flag #4: No Verifiable Track Record or Online Presence

A buyer with no record anyone can check is hard to hold to its word. Public records show whether a company exists and whether it has bought houses before.

  • What it looks like: a brand name with no registered company behind it and no purchases in its name.
  • How to check it: each state's business search, which NASS links by state, shows a company's status. County deed records show past purchases. A deed is the document that transfers ownership of a house.
  • What a legitimate buyer does instead: gives its exact legal name, so its record is easy to find.

Red Flag #5: Vague or Evasive Answers to Basic Questions

Vague answers about the price, the costs, or the buyer's identity are a warning sign, because the contract will settle each of those points. A sound buyer can say how it reached its number and who will close.

  • What it looks like: "an industry formula," costs left for later, or no straight answer about assignment. Assignment means the buyer transfers its contract to another buyer before closing. A wholesaler is a buyer whose business is doing that for a fee. Both are legal business practices, though some states regulate them. Hiding them is the warning sign.
  • How to check it: the buyer line in the contract. "Company or assigns" means another buyer may close.
  • What a legitimate buyer does instead: names the nearby sales it used, lists seller costs in dollars, and says plainly whether it may assign the contract.

Red Flag #6: Last-Minute Contract Changes or "Closing Table Hijacking"

A price cut or new fee near closing, with no documented reason, is a warning sign. A signed contract sets the terms, and a buyer generally cannot change them without the seller's written agreement.

  • What it looks like: a lower price at the closing table over issues visible at the first walkthrough, or a closing date that keeps slipping.
  • How to check it: the final settlement statement placed next to the signed contract shows any change line by line.
  • What a legitimate buyer does instead: raises a real problem, such as a lien on the title, as soon as it finds one, with the document that shows it.

Red Flag #7: Offers Significantly Above Market Value

An offer far above what nearby houses sold for may be bait for a later price cut. Cash buyers usually price in repairs and resale costs, so a cash offer normally sits below a listing price.

  • What it looks like: a high number with loose terms, such as a long inspection period that lets the buyer walk away.
  • How to check it: recent nearby sales in county records, and the contract's contingencies (conditions that let the buyer cancel). The guide to spotting a lowball offer covers the low end of the range.
  • What a legitimate buyer does instead: explains its number with nearby sales and keeps its conditions few and short.

Red Flag #8: Avoiding Licensed Title Companies or Attorneys

A buyer who wants to skip the title company removes the neutral party that makes sure the seller is paid before ownership changes. A title company checks ownership, holds the money in escrow (a neutral account until closing), and records the deed. In some states a closing attorney does this job.

  • What it looks like: a request to sign the deed now and be paid later, or a title company the buyer owns without saying so.
  • How to check it: a call to the title company, at a number found independently, confirms the file is open and the payout instructions are real.
  • What a legitimate buyer does instead: closes through an independent title company and pays at the same closing where the deed is signed.

The FBI's 2025 IC3 report counted 12,368 real estate fraud complaints, with $275,110,419 in reported losses. That category also covers rental and timeshare fraud, so it shows scale, not a rate for cash buyers.

How to Protect Yourself: Checklist

Most protection comes from a few documents and one neutral title company. A sale that is on track usually has each item below in place before closing day.

  1. The company is on record

    The legal name on the contract is the same as an active company in the state business search.

  2. The funds are confirmed

    A recent proof-of-funds letter names the company that signs, and the bank has confirmed it where it will.

  3. The deposit sits with a neutral holder

    The title company holds the earnest money and has sent a receipt.

  4. The buyer line is clear

    The seller knows whether the contract says "or assigns," and what that means for who closes.

  5. No fee is due before closing

    The contract shows nothing the seller pays before the closing date.

  6. Payout instructions are confirmed by phone

    The title company has confirmed wire instructions at a number found independently, not one taken from an email.

Where to Report a Problem With a Cash Buyer

The office that takes a report depends on the problem. The FTC takes fraud reports, the FBI takes wire fraud, and HUD's inspector general takes fraud in HUD programs such as FHA loans.

Where to report a problem with a cash buyer, by type of problem
ProblemWho takes the reportWhat they do, in their own wordsLink
An upfront fee for mortgage or foreclosure helpFederal Trade Commission, and the state attorney generalThe FTC says a report goes into "a secure national database available to local, state, and federal law enforcement."ReportFraud.ftc.gov; NAAG AG finder
A wire or closing-funds fraudFBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3), and local policeIC3 calls itself "the central hub for reporting cyber-enabled crime." It says it "cannot respond directly to every submission."ic3.gov
A forged or pressured deed transferLocal police or sheriff; the county land records office shows what was recordedThe CFPB points to the local police or sheriff "using their nonemergency phone number or website." The FTC says an owner can "check your title for free with your state's land records office."CFPB guidance; FTC title alert
An unlicensed person acting as a brokerThe state real estate commissionThe commission licenses brokers. ARELLO's search lets anyone "verify the current status of real estate practitioners license or registration."ARELLO license search
A scam tied to an FHA loan (a mortgage insured by the Federal Housing Administration)HUD Office of Inspector GeneralHUD's contact page directs "allegations of fraud, waste, abuse, mismanagement or whistleblower related matters" to the OIG Hotline, (800) 347-3735.HUD contact page
A problem with a mortgage company or lenderConsumer Financial Protection Bureau"We'll send your complaint directly to the company so it can review the issues in your complaint." The CFPB adds that "[m]ost companies respond within 15 days."CFPB complaints
A contract dispute with a buyerThe state attorney general, or a real estate attorneyNAAG lists the attorney general of every state, with a profile for each. An attorney can read the contract itself.NAAG AG finder
Behind on payments and unsure whom to trustA HUD-approved housing counselorHUD's page reads: "Search online for a HUD-approved Housing Counselor near you or call (800) 569-4287."HUD contact page

Sources: each agency's own page, read November 2026. No agency promises an outcome for a single report.

Which States Require Wholesale Buyers to Disclose?

Some states require a wholesale buyer to tell the seller in writing that the contract may be assigned, and some give the seller time to cancel. The table covers five states whose laws were read on official state sites in November 2026.

State laws on disclosure by wholesale buyers and seller cancellation rights (checked November 2026)
StateWhat the buyer must discloseSeller's right to cancel, if anyLaw
DelawareA wholesale contract "shall prominently include the following information" in a form the Real Estate Commission approves, "available in English, Spanish, and Haitian Creole."Until "midnight of the twenty-first calendar day after the date when the consumer executed the agreement or contract" or "until conveyance, whichever occurs first." The right "is not waivable."§ 2940 of 24 Del. C.
IowaBefore signing, in writing to all parties: "The legal identities of all parties to the wholesale transaction" and "An explanation of the wholesaling process."If that disclosure is missing, the seller "may cancel the contract at any time prior to the closing of the sale of the residential property without penalty."§ 543B.6A of the Iowa Code
Maryland"Before entering into a contract of sale for residential property," a wholesale buyer of an owner-occupied house "shall disclose in writing to the owner of the property that the wholesale buyer may assign the contract of sale to another person."The owner "may rescind a contract of sale to a wholesale buyer without penalty at any time before closing" if the notice was not given and the contract is assigned.§ 10-715 of Real Property
OklahomaWritten notice "before execution of any contract or written agreement of their intent to assign or sell their equitable interest in the property for a higher price than what you are being offered.""within two (2) business days after the execution of the Contract," or "at any time if the Wholesaler has failed to provide the required disclosures."§ 858-314 of 59 O.S. (Real Estate Commission form)
PennsylvaniaThe contract must state "that the agreement or contract is for a wholesale transaction" and state the seller's right to cancel."until midnight of the 30th day after the date when the consumer executed the agreement or contract, or until conveyance, whichever occurs first." The right "shall not be waivable."Act 52 of 2024 (§ 610)

Sources: each state's official statute or Real Estate Commission page, read November 2026. Quotes are exact; laws change.

Other states may have rules too. A state attorney general's office or a real estate attorney can say what applies to a given contract.

How can Propcash help you check a cash buyer?

Propcash is a direct cash homebuyer, and the eight checks in this guide apply to us too. Our purchase agreement reads "Propcash or assigns," and that is disclosed in the agreement itself. Our offers are based on local market data, and we'll show you how we got to our number.

There are no fees charged to you, no obligation, and our offers don't expire, so there is time to run every check on us. You pick your closing date. If a cash sale isn't your best move, we'll tell you. A Propcash cash offer can sit next to any other offer while you compare.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are most "we buy houses" companies legitimate businesses?

Generally, yes. Most are registered businesses that buy houses for cash, often as-is and on a short timeline. The usual trade-off is price, since a cash offer tends to come in below what a listing might bring. Trouble tends to come from specific behaviors, such as an upfront fee, pressure to sign, or a hidden assignment.

Why is a cash offer usually lower than a listing price?

A cash buyer usually takes the house as it is and prices in repairs, holding costs, resale costs, and its own profit. A listing may bring a higher price, but it often comes with repairs, showings, commissions, and months of waiting. The fair comparison is the money left after costs on each path, not the two headline prices.

What happens if I already signed a contract with a cash buyer?

A signed contract is generally binding, but some states give sellers a right to cancel a wholesale contract. Pennsylvania allows 30 days, Delaware 21 days, and Oklahoma two business days, while Iowa and Maryland allow cancellation before closing when a required disclosure was missing. The contract's terms and the state's law decide what applies. A real estate attorney or the state attorney general's office can say what a specific contract allows.

Can a cash buyer assign my contract to someone else?

Often, yes, if the contract allows it. An "or assigns" clause after the buyer's name lets the buyer transfer its rights to another buyer before closing. Assignment is a legal business practice, and some states require the buyer to disclose it in writing first. The buyer line and the assignment clause in the contract show who may end up closing.

Is selling to a cash buyer during foreclosure risky?

A sale can be a sound way out of foreclosure, but scammers do target owners who are behind on payments. The FTC warns that transferring the deed does not transfer the mortgage, so the owner may still owe the loan. The FTC points owners to a certified housing counselor for free help, and HUD lists approved counselors online and at (800) 569-4287.

Who takes a report about a cash buyer I think is a scam?

The FTC takes fraud reports at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, and its mortgage relief page also names the state attorney general. Wire fraud goes to the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center at ic3.gov, and a forged deed is a matter for the local police. Scams tied to an FHA loan go to the HUD Office of Inspector General hotline at (800) 347-3735.

How common is real estate fraud?

The FBI's 2025 IC3 annual report counted 12,368 real estate fraud complaints, with $275,110,419 in reported losses. That category also covers rental and timeshare fraud, so it is not a rate for cash buyer sales. It does show that fraud around real estate is reported thousands of times a year.

About this guide

Reviewed by the Propcash Editorial Team under our editorial standards. Published by Propcash, a direct cash buyer of houses. This guide is general information. Laws, fees, and market figures change, so check the current rules for your state.

See what we'd pay for your house

Sell as-is. No repairs, no showings. Close in as few as 7 days.

Checking a cash buyer? Put our offer next to any other. Our offers are based on local market data, with no fees and no obligation.

Free. No obligation.

Enter your address to see values near you